Rowing machines are one of the best pieces of exercise equipment that you can own if you want to get in shape. They provide a complete, full-body cardio workout, working your legs, abdomen, arms, shoulders, and lower back, all while providing a steady calorie burn in the process. Rowing is also a great compliment to any existing workout routine you may have. Rowing is also very simple, exerts hardly any stress on your joints, like running or jogging can, and virtually anyone of any fitness or experience level can do it.
In order to help you select the right rowing machine, we thoroughly analyzed and compared 45 different rowers, eventually narrowing the field down to just the five best units. In the process, we invested over 28 hours on research and writing to create this list, buying guide and comparison chart.
Best Overall: Concept2 Model D Exercise Rowing Machine
The Concept2 Model D is easily the best rowing machine on the market. The sleek design of this unit is almost deceptive because this is one of the sturdiest and most durable rowers in the world, and is designed for heavy use and serious workouts.
The unit’s flywheel design includes a spiral damper, which can be adjusted to change the airflow around the flywheel. This allows you to alter the feel of the stroke to one that is most comfortable to you. The machine is also designed to keep noise to a minimum, so you can even use it an apartment without having to worry about disturbing your neighbors.
The Concept2’s built-in performance monitor allows you to track rate, distance, calories burned, and watts generated each time you work out. You can also use Bluetooth technology to connect a heart monitor to complete your tracking, allowing you to upload your data to a USB at the end of your workout so you can track your progress on a daily basis.
This machine uses air for resistance, so it doesn’t have an adjustable tension system. Instead, the resistance is completely dynamic and determined by the user – pulling harder increases the resistance and vice versa.
You’ll also like the fact that the Concept2 was designed for convenience. The quick lock release system allows you to separate the two parts of the machine for easy storage. The machine also has caster wheels, allowing you to easily move the unit around your workout area. In addition, assembly is simple and only requires a few tools. The rower comes with a five year manufacturer’s warranty on the frame and a two year warranty on all moving parts and the monitoring device. This super solidly built machine can support individuals weighing up to 500 pounds.
If we had to mention one drawback of the Concept2, it would be the fact that it doesn’t store your workout information in the monitoring system. As a result, you’ll have to download the information and track it on your computer.
WaterRower Natural Rowing Machine
The WaterRower is the ultimate rowing machine for those who want the feel of rowing on actual water. Created to simulate the actual rowing motion felt in the competitive sport of rowing, this machine provides a superior workout while putting minimal stress on your joints.
The WaterRower’s flywheel is immersed into a water tank where it replicates the sound and feel of rowing through water, and resistance is achieved by the rate in which you row. To add more intensity to your workout, you simply row faster. This simulates the actual rowing motion in water, and each repetition with the machine will work out approximately 84{88454e838380835437410b8dd4980e42836d50c1d7c06d32c28ecbc57e5157a9} of your body’s muscles. There are only two “paddles” on the flywheel giving it a truly authentic feel. Water levels can also be changed to further increase or decrease the intensity of the workout.
The frame of the rower is constructed out of solid ash wood. Ash wood was selected for its ability to absorb sound and withstand rigorous use. The wood is then stained and oiled so that it compliments any area where it is used.
The main drawback to this machine is the weight. The natural rowing machine is built to be stored in an upright position when not in use. However, lifting this machine may be a little difficult for some people. The weight is listed at 117 pounds which is over double of any other rowing machine.
Best Value: Stamina Avari Programmable Magnetic Exercise Rowing Machine
The Stamina Avari is the flagship model in the Stamina line of rowing machines and, in our opinion, offers the best “bang for your buck.” This unit uses magnetic resistance, which makes it great at not only giving you an excellent cardiovascular and aerobic workout, but makes it very quiet as well. This streamlined machine is built using very sturdy aluminum beams, making it light enough for anyone to easily manage the machine, yet durable enough for heavy, daily use.
The unit has a LED backlit monitor system that provides users with 12 monitoring programs that can be used with or without the heartrate strap. Seven of these programs will automatically adjust the magnetic tension on the machine to accommodate your abilities and increase your performance.
The Stamina Avari’s handlebars are connected to the flywheel system using a thick nylon rope. The use of nylon decreases noise when in use, and helps reduce the regular wear typically seen on other models that use chains. The use of nylon also eliminates the need to oil a chain, which can be a hassle to many people.
In addition, the unit’s feet are held in place on the foot pegs with Velcro straps, and the seat is molded to give it a more comfortable feeling while in use. This machine is equipped to handle individuals who weigh up to 275 pounds.
The Stamina Avari’s biggest drawback is that the Velcro straps on the foot pegs tend to wear out over time. With continual use, you may need to replace these straps after 6 months.
4 Stamina Air Rower Home Rowing Machine
The Stamina Air Rower is another solidly constructed rowing machine that uses air for resistance levels. Ideal for beginners and more experienced rowers alike, this machine allows you to determine the intensity of your workout by the speed that you row the machine. The faster you row, the higher the wind resistance and workout intensity.
Constructed from steel, the body of this machine is very sturdy and will withstand continual use. The rowing strap is made from a strong nylon that reduces noise levels when in use and does not require oiling. The foot pegs also have nylon straps that secure your feet in place during use.
The workout monitor displays speed, time, distance and the amount of calories burned each session. The seat of the machine is padded for extra comfort, and the handgrips are molded for easy gripping and to lessen strain on your wrists and hands when using the machine. In addition, the Stamina Air Rower has rubber feet, which not only reduces noise but also allows you to move the machine much easier.
The Stamina Air Rower does have a few downsides, however. For one, because this is an “air” rower, some beginners may find themselves getting discouraged initially when using this machine, as rowers that use air resistance may take some time to get used to. More experienced users, however, should not have any trouble adjusting their intensity levels using this system. Another thing to be aware of is that this machine is not meant to be used by anyone weighing more than 250 pounds.
5 Best Budget Model: Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515 Magnetic Rowing Machine
If you’re looking for a decent quality rowing machine and don’t want to spend an arm and a leg to get one, we recommend the Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515, a very affordable magnetic resistance rowing machine that you can buy for well under $300. Even though this unit has a highly streamlined design, it doesn’t take away much from the durability of the machine, and is a great choice for people who are new to exercising with rowers.
The Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515 has 8 different intensity settings, and the magnetic resistance can be adjusted manually in order to increase or decrease intensity. The monitor provides you with information on how long you’ve worked out, calories burned, and the number of rows you have completed. In addition, there is a built-in heart rate monitor positioned in the hand grip that will post your heartrate on the monitor throughout the workout.
In addition, the unit’s padded seat provides extra comfort during long workouts, and the machine is also equipped with large foot pads and nylon straps to secure any size foot during their workout routine. This rower is also relatively lightweight compared to many other models, and can be easily folded for storage.
The Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515’s only real drawback, albeit minor, is that it doesn’t track distance. This may or may not be a big deal to you, but many people like to see how far they have rowed and not just how many strokes they made or calories they’ve burned. Also, this machine can only safely support individual weights of up to 250 pounds.
Buying Guide: How To Select The Best Rowing Machine
So now that you are ready to purchase a machine, it is important that you take the time to learn about the differences in these machines, what to search for in a machine, and what types of accessories you may want to compliment your equipment.
The Four Types Of Rowing Machines
There are four standard types of rowing machines. These include:
- Water Rowing Machines
- Hydraulic Rowing Machines
- Air Flow Rowing Machines
- Magnetic Rowing Machines
Water Rowing Machines
A water rowing machine is a type of machine that best simulates actual rowing on water. These machines are preferred by competitive rowers because the rowing motion in the water actually feels just like the real thing. These machines are very heavy duty and are generally constructed from solid wood.
Water rowing machines do not have a motor on them, so the only noise that it generates is the sound of the paddles moving in the water tank. This is generally a pleasant sound for most people and also helps with simulating actually rowing a boat.
Water machines provide a superior workout and resistance is based on the speed and intensity that they user puts into the machine. These machines usually can accommodate people of larger sizes more easily than smaller machines.
Water resistance machines are generally the highest priced machines on the market because they are custom built from solid wood.
Hydraulic Rowing Machines
Hydraulic rowing machines use a hydraulic piston to move the machine and the flywheel. These are usually smaller machines and are intended mainly for home use.
Hydraulic machines are often the quietist of all rowing machines because the hydraulic system is self-lubricating. These machines often have monitoring systems that can track your workout progress as you are rowing and also enable you to set the machine to different intensity levels. Most of these types of machines can be easily adjusted with a knob or a dial.
Hydraulic machines can be limited by the amount of resistance that they can create for the user. These machines are preferred by beginners or by those who only want a basic workout in their homes or only intend to use the machine when they can’t get to the gym.
Out of all the rowing machine styles available, hydraulic machines are usually the lowest priced machines available.
Air Flow Rowing Machines
Air flow rowing machines are the most common type of machine used at home and in gym settings. The flywheel is set up to spin like a box fan and resistance is determined by the amount of speed from the user. When a person rows quickly, the resistance builds. Some of these machines also have adjustable resistance so that the user can start at higher levels and build their intensity level.
Air flow machines provide a very good workout and users can be at beginner or professional level when they begin using this and experience the benefits. Most are equipped with a monitoring system that will track everything from pulse rate to distance rowed. Many are also interactive with other devices via Bluetooth technology allowing users to track their progress in different apps.
It should be noted that these machines can get noisy from the “whirring” sound of the air coming out. While many manufacturers have had the ability to decrease this noise, it still will occur. These machines are very sturdily built and most can handle individuals up to 500 pounds.
Air flow machines range from moderate to high pricing depending on the amenities that the user decides on with the machine.
Magnetic Rowing Machines
Magnetic rowing machines use the power of magnets to adjust the resistance of the machine. These machines operate very quietly because of the way they are constructed and are perfect for apartments or office settings.
Magnetic machines have adjustable resistance settings that are manually determined by the user. A few of these machines have programmable magnetic settings based on programs contained in their monitoring applications. Most of these machines have advanced monitoring systems to tell the user how they are performing during a workout.
The only real drawback to this type of machine is that the resistance level can only go so high before they are to maximum capacity. The strength of the magnets will determine the intensity maximum. This may be an issue for high performance athletes who continue to build intensity in their workout sessions.
Magnetic machines range in prices from very low to high. Price will depend on manufacturer and amenities that come with the machine.
What To Look For In A Rowing Machine
Once you have decided on the type of machine that you would like to purchase, there are a few additional things that you should research before you make your final decision. These include:
- Materials Used For Construction
- Performance Monitor Options
- Seat, Foot Rests and Handle Design
- Height and Weight Requirements
- Storage Features
- Warranty
Materials Used For Construction
You will find rowing machines constructed from a variety of materials. Machines that are considered very sturdy include those made from hard woods like Ash, and steel. Some fortified aluminum machines are also very durable. Machines constructed from aluminum and composite materials may not be as durable as others which is a consideration for those who will use the machine for heavy workouts.
Performance Monitor Options
Check to see what options the performance monitor offers. Some will be very basic models that only offer you the ability to track speed and calories burned. Some devices will be able to be integrated with heart rate machines and fitness apps. A majority will allow you to download your results to an USB drive to track your progress on your PC.
Additionally, you will want to look to see if the device is backlit with LCD lighting so that it is easily readable. You will also want to determine if it has preset programs for exercising or if it allows you to row freestyle.
Seat, Foot Rest and Handle Design
Look closely at the seat. Some are hard molded plastic seats that are made to “conform” to your body. However, everybody is built differently and this type of seat may be uncomfortable for you. Look for a seat that is flat and padded so that you can make yourself comfortable.
The foot rest or foot pegs should be large enough to accommodate your foot. Pegs that are too small will lead to your foot slipping during the routine which could lead to injury. Also, make sure that you check if the machine has foot straps and how they are closed. Velcro straps may wear out much faster than other types of straps.
Handle design should be ergonomically correct. You want a handle that does not force you to hold your hands or arms too high. You may also want to look for grips that are molded so you can easily hold onto them while working out.
Height and Weight Requirements
Every machine is constructed differently. Even the length of the track will be different from each manufacturer. It is important that you check to see what the maximum height requirements are for the machine so that you do not purchase one that will not allow you to fully straighten your legs during the workout. You will also want to check if the seat is adjustable if you are sharing the machine with someone who is not the same height.
You should also check the weight requirements of the machine. Many smaller machines or those constructed of lighter metals have a much lighter weight limit than those constructed of metal or wood. For the best results, look for a machine that can accommodate weights that is at least 25 pounds higher than your current weight.
Storage Features
Many people have limited space to have workout equipment so they need to be able to store the machine when not in use. Look at the storage features. Many machines can easily fold or can come apart for storage. Look for ones that have built in casters for easy movement.
Warranty
The manufacturer’s warranty will vary from each company. Warranties will vary from 90 days to lifetime coverage depending on the type of machine and who made the product. Always review the warranty closely.
Add On Amenities
Once you have decided on the machine and all of its features, you will still need to determine if you want any additional amenities. Some of these amenities may include:
- Mat for the machine
- Additional heart rate monitoring equipment
- Fitness tracking software
Many rowing enthusiasts have found that by purchasing a mat for underneath their machine they can reduce even more of the noise associated with working out. These mats are also great for protecting the flooring and giving the machine a little more cushioning (shock absorption) for intense workouts.
Additional software for your monitoring system or fitness tracking software or apps may also be beneficial to your workout. This will all depend on your personal choices.
Once you understand all the parts to purchasing the right rowing machine, you will find that you will be able to pick the right machine for your workout needs.
Comparison Chart
Our Top Pick
$$$$$
Air
Yes
500 lbs.
96 x 24 x 28
57 lbs.
5-yr Frame; 2-yr Parts
Best Value
$$$
Magnetic
Yes
275 lbs.
81 x 20 x 25
80 lbs.
3-yr Frame; 90-days Parts
Best Budget Model
$
Magnetic
Yes
250 lbs.
82 x 19 x 23
59 lbs.
90-days Frame & Parts
Top Rated
$$$$$
Water
Yes
1000 lbs.
84 x 22 x 21
117 lbs.
5-yr Frame; 3-yr Parts
Good
$$
Air
Yes
250 lbs.
77 x 18 x 22
56 lbs.
3-yr Frame; 90-days Parts
Top 7 Treadmills
7 Best Elliptical Machines
Top 7 Exercise Bikes