One of the most important purchases you’ll ever have to make when you bring a new baby home is a quality, reliable car seat. So many factors go into buying the right car seat for your child, such as safety, convenience, size and more. It’s vital to have a seat that meets all safety standards and rates high in customer satisfaction. Having a great car seat can make the difference for both the child and the parent, especially when comfort comes into play.
With so many brands and models on the market, finding the right one can be difficult. But we wanted to make things a little easier for you, the consumer, which is why we spent 22+ hours exhaustively comparing and analyzing 35 different car seats in order to create this buying guide and comparison chart.
Best Overall: Graco 4ever All-in-One Convertible Baby Car Seat
The Graco 4ever All-in-One is our top pick and we give it our highest recommendation. This ultra versatile car seat’s Simply Safe Adjust Harness System allows you to adjust the height of the headrest and harness in just one motion, ensuring that your child is secured in the seat properly at all times. The 10-position headrest adjusts to your child’s needs as they grow, ensuring the proper fit and optimal safety. Designed to last up to ten years or until your child reaches 120 pounds, the Graco 4Ever car seat will fit your child from the time they are an infant to the time they are old enough to just need the booster part of the seat.
The infant car seat offers soft inserts that will help keep your child comfortable and cozy on both short and long trips. The Graco 4ever can later be converted from a rear-facing seat to a forward-facing one once your child reaches the weight and height requirements to turn around. Once the seat is forward facing, toddlers can use the two integrated cup holders to hold their own drinks and snacks. And as your child grows older, the seat can be reclined in six different ways.
Pros
- Parents and caregivers never have to purchase another car seat when their child grows
- Machine-washable
- Easy to install and use latch system
- Recline feature is great for children who fall asleep in the car
Cons
- Meant to be installed directly in your vehicle and left there. You can’t transport the child in it
- Fabric may not be breathable in hotter climates and may need to be washed more often
Diono Radian RXT All-In-One Convertible Car Seat
The Diono Radian RXT is another superb “all-in-one” car seat that fits your child from infancy all the way up to their toddler years. It is one of the only car seats that has a full steel frame, which makes it one of the safest car seats available on the market. The Diono Radian was NCAP crash tested at a force twice that of a standard car crash test, and employs a Safe Stop energy absorbing harness that keeps your child safe and secure. The Radian RXT actually lowers the child’s center of gravity while they are in it, which causes less force to be exerted on the child if an accident occurs.
This seat fits rear-facing children who weigh between five and 45 pounds and then converts to a forward-facing car seat for children 20-80 pounds. Once your child hits the weight and height requirements, the car seat can be used as a booster, up to 120 pounds. Children will enjoy the reinforced head support that adjusts for added comfort, as well as memory foam in the actual seat that adds comfort for infants to older kids. The five shoulder, three buckle positions offer a more comfortable ride for the child, and most mid-sized vehicles can fit three of these seats side-by-side because of the slim design of the seat.
Pros
- Folds flat and can be carried like a backpack for easy travel/storage
- Ten-year product life
- One of the only full steel framed car seats available for purchase
- FAA approved for airplanes
- Machine-washable cover
Cons
- May be difficult to install correctly
- Heavy to carry
- Pricey
Best Car Seat & Stroller Travel System: Britax B-Agile/B-Safe 35
The Britax B-Agile/B-Safe 35 is a car seat/stroller combination, and is a great choice for parents and caregivers who want a convenient system for transporting their baby from the car to their home and vice versa. By combining both car seat and stroller into one, it makes the unit significantly more versatile than a car seat alone. The stroller that it comes with, called the “B-Agile,” is true to its name, as you can navigate and maneuver it through crowded spaces with ease. It can also be conveniently folded up with one hand for easy storage and transport. The front of the stroller uses a three-wheel configuration that allows the wheels to swivel effortlessly through tighter spaces.
The car seat that it comes with, the “B-Safe 35,” has a number of safety features, including the Britax-exclusive SafeCell Impact Protection configuration, which will protect your child beyond the federal safety standards imposed for car seats. A steel frame strengthens the car seat while the base compresses to absorb extra energy during a collision. The car seat is designed with a deep shell that fits snugly in a vehicle and minimizes any side-to-side movement. When you are ready to take your child out of the car, the infant seat attaches to the stroller with one simple click.
Pros
- Easy Assembly and Disassembly
- Good for traveling
- Easy adjustable harness straps
- Compact and lightweight
- Car seat has a five-year extended warranty
Cons
- Will need a new stroller for a toddler over 55 pounds
- No foot rest on the stroller for children
- Head rest of the car seat may not support as well as others
- Narrow seat may be too tight for heavier children
4 Best Value: Evenflo Symphony DLX Convertible All-In-One Car Seat
If you’re looking for the car seat that will give you the best “bang for your buck,” then the Evenflo Symphony DLX is the one you want. This versatile car seat can be used from when your baby is a rear-facing infant to later when it’s a front-facing toddler, and again when they are old enough to use it as a booster seat. The Evenflo Symphony DLX safely protects all rear-facing infants from five to 40 pounds and forward-facing toddlers from 22 to 65 pounds. The high-backed booster seat offers support and protection for children weighing 40 to 110 pounds. The multiple position recline feature allows for your child’s comfort while they are sleeping.
The Symphony DLX easily installs in any vehicle in just 60 seconds with the use of Evenflo’s elite, auto-retracting Sure LATCH connectors. No pulling is necessary when you secure this seat as they simply click and push into place for a super-snug fit. As the child grows, the infinite slide harness will easily slide with them so they are safely snapped in every time with no reworking of the harness itself. The five-point harness system allows for easy adjusting when getting your child in and out of your vehicle.
Pros
- Cup holder included
- Made in the United States
- Adjustable recliner
- Excellent value for your money
Cons
- Neck portion of the car seat may not provide adequate support for a baby
- Head pillow may be too bulky for some
- Must take the seat apart to pull off the cover to wash
5 Graco Size4Me 65 Rapid Remove Convertible Baby Car Seat
The Graco Size4Me 65 offers a number of useful features, and is suitable for both rear-facing infants and forward-facing toddlers alike. The Size4Me 65 is a convertible car seat that will hold a four to 40-pound rear-facing infant and then turn to hold a forward-facing child from 20 to 60 pounds. The Simply Safe Adjust harness system grows with your child, as it automatically adjusts the harness and headrest height with eight different settings. The Graco Size4Me 65 uses EPS foam and has a removable head/body support that is guaranteed to keep your baby’s head in place while driving. There are three recline and two buckle positions that will keep babies and toddlers safe and snug.
One of the best features of this car seat is the RapidRemove cover that comes off with just a few snaps. You do not need to uninstall the car seat to clean the cover, and the cover itself is machine-washable. This car seat has been side-impact tested and has met or exceeded all applicable United States safety standards. It has also been side impact tested for occupant retention based only on the built-in five-point harness system, as well.
Pros
- Reclines easily for long rides
- Thicker shoulder pads for added comfort
- Easy latch system makes it simple to move from car to car
- FAA approved for flying
- The car seat is one-piece and does not use a base
- Seat is secured with a one-second latch to your vehicle
Cons
- Larger model may take up more room in the back seat
- Bottom buckle latch may push into the child
- Seat will not connect to any strollers
6 Best Budget Model: Evenflo Tribute LX Convertible Car Seat
The Evenflo Tribute LX is a safe and reliable car seat that’s also very affordable. This car seat comes in four different colors and is designed for both rear-facing infants from five to 30 pounds to forward-facing infants from 22 to 40 pounds. The four shoulder strap positions of the seat will accommodate children as they grow, which allows the seat to be used longer. An upfront harness adjustment and upfront buckle release makes it even more convenient for parents getting their child in and out of the car. Both the harness and buckles are covered with soft foam, allowing your child to be comfortable during the ride.
Additionally, the seat reclines for longer car trips, and a plush head pillow will keep your child’s head and neck in place during the ride as well as providing some extra comfort. The seat pads of the Evenflo Tribute LX are easily removable and machine washable. The Evenflo Tribute LX also meets or exceeds all Federal Safety Standards along with Evenflo’s own side impact test standards. These tests use energy levels approximately twice that of the Federal Crash Test Standard for car seats with multiple shoulder harness positions. Furthermore, the seat’s liner is constructed from energy absorbing foam and provides both safety and comfort for your child.
Pros
- Lightweight and compact
- Easy to install correctly
- Designed, assembled, molded and tested in the United States
- Multiple shoulder harness positions provide a better fit and longer use
- Removable head pillow
- Inexpensive
Cons
- Provided cup holder is meant only for foam or plastic cups, not standard child-proof cups
- Does not convert into a booster seat for older children
Buying Guide: How To Choose The Best Car Seat
Type
You’ll want to consider the different types of car seats available for your child. All car seats have both slight and major differences in their shapes, the height and weight requirements, how they are secured in the vehicle and more. There are three common car seat types: rear-facing, forward-facing, and boosters. We’ll take an in-depth look at each one.
Rear-Facing Car Seats
A rear-facing car seat is designed for infants as soon as they come home from the hospital up to a year or older. Having your car seat rear-facing is important for the safety of your small baby, as they protect the fragile bones and muscles of a newborn baby’s neck, as well as the rest of their body. A rear-facing car seat is installed with the baby facing the back of the vehicle. A rear-facing car seat may be installed in the front seat but this should never be done if there are airbags in the passenger seat that can’t be turned off.
Rear-facing car seats may also be used as baby carriers. With these types of car seats, the whole seat lifts out of a base that stays attached to the vehicle. Many also attach directly to a stroller.
Forward-Facing Car Seats
Once your child reaches a year old or meets the height and weight requirements, the seat can be turned forward. A forward-facing seat should only be used if your baby can hold his or her head up on their own. If your child’s legs hit the seat uncomfortably in the rear-facing position, it may be time to turn the seat around. However, be sure to check your state laws concerning the height and weight requirements, as they vary from state-to-state. Switching your child to a forward-facing position can result in injury or death if they are not ready for it.
Again, this type of seat may also be used in conjuncture with a stroller by pulling it out of the base strapped in the car and attaching it directly.
Booster Seats
Children who are under 12 years old and who meet the state’s height and weight requirements may sit in a booster seat once they outgrow the forward-facing car seat. An older child doesn’t need extra security that the harnesses provide on rear and forward-facing seats. Booster seats help to raise your child up to a high enough position so that he or she can safely wear the original seat belt provided by the vehicle. If your car doesn’t have a headrest, a high-backed booster seat will be needed.
Many car seat companies offer models that are “all-in-one” or “convertible”, meaning that it’s a car seat that can be used as both a rear and front-facing seat, and then can be converted into a booster when your child is old enough. While these models are more expensive up front, they pay for themselves later on when you do not have to buy any additional equipment for your children.
Safety Features
One of the most important features in a car seat is how well it holds up in safety tests. Review the car seat on the manufacturer’s website to make sure they have followed all safety laws and have put the car seat through the appropriate crash tests. The best car crash tests will involve the car seat in a crash up to two times the Federal Crash Test Standards. Read reviews to find out how well a particular model holds up in a car accident.
Also, never ignore any potential recalls. If there has been a safety issue with a particular car seat, the manufacturer may issue a recall. If you have already bought a car seat and there is a recall on it, immediately find out how to get the seat either replaced or repaired before using it again. Additionally, do not buy a used car seat, as tempting as the price can be. Used car seats may have parts or pieces that are not working correctly that you cannot clearly see, or may have been broken in an accident. The frame of the seat and materials may be damaged, causing the seat to malfunction if a new accident occurs. It’s always recommended to put your money into new car seat for your child’s safety.
When installing your new car seat, be sure that it is put in your vehicle correctly before you drive with your baby or toddler. Read the instruction manual top to bottom before installing the seat. Many manufacturers now offer how-to videos either on their website or You-Tube that gives step-by-step instructions on how to properly install their seat. For added protection, contact your local fire department and ask if they will check to ensure your seat is installed safely. Most local fire departments offer this service for free and may even hold special hours in thei community for safety checks.
Five-Point Harness
Most infant and toddler seats come with a five-point harness system that adds the most protection in the event of a car crash. A five-point harness will secure your child across their chest, shoulders and legs and will distribute the energy from an impact across the torso of the baby or child in the event of an accident. Most models now automatically come with this type of system in place already, but it is still important to make sure your car seat has it. Also, make sure the harness can be adjusted easily. As your child grows, you will have to let out the harness a bit at a time to ensure your child is comfortable, so you will want to invest in a car seat with easily adjusted straps. Also be sure that the harness is escape-proof. While many children will do their best to get out of their car seat, the appropriate harness can help your odds of keeping them properly buckled.
Ease of Use and Convenience
Of course, everyone wants a car seat that is safe and will be useful for years. But you will also want a car seat that can be easily cleaned, stores well and is simple to use. Babies and small children make messes often, so you will want a car seat that has a removable cover. Most seats nowadays come with the cover attached to the car seat by snaps, Velcro or elastic straps that pull off easily. However, some models require you to take the whole seat out and off of its base before you can get to the cover itself, which can be a hassle when your child spills or gets sick frequently. You’ll also want a car seat that can easily be wiped down around the cup holder and edges.
Another convenient type of car seat is the kind that snaps into a stroller. These seats lift easily from their base in the car and snap into a stroller that usually comes with the seat or can be specially bought. This is the perfect type of car seat set for parents who travel frequently or who are on the go. Look for a stroller that can be folded down effortlessly with one hand and stores easily in your trunk or home. Some models will only work for children up to a certain weight limit, however. After the child surpasses that, you will need to purchase a separate stroller for them.
A new car seat is surely one of more important baby items you will ever purchase. The right car seat will protect your child in the event of an accident, but will also allow them to ride comfortably in your vehicle. Always consider the factors involved before making the decision to buy a car seat. Understanding what to look for will help you make an informed, smart decision when you purchase your child their new ride.
Comparison Chart
Our Top Pick
$$$$$
Convertible
4-40 lbs. / Up to 1″ Below Top
22-65 lbs. / 27-52 in.
30-120 lbs. / 38-57 in.
23 lbs.
Best Value
$$$
Convertible
5-40 lbs. / 19-40 in.
22-40 lbs. / 28-50 in.
40-110 lbs. / 44-57 in.
25 lbs.
Best Budget Model
$
Convertible
5-30 lbs. / 19-37 in.
22-40 lbs. / 28-40 in.
No Booster Option
9 lbs.
Top Rated
$$$$$
Convertible
5-45 lbs. / Up to 44 in.
20-80 lbs. / Up to 57 in.
50-120 lbs. / Up to 57 in.
22 lbs.
Very Good
$$$$$
Convertible
5-40 lbs. / Up to 1″ Below Top
22-65 lbs. / Up to 50 in.
No Booster Option
25 lbs.
Good
$$$
Convertible
4-40 lbs. / Up to 1″ Below Top
22-65 lbs. / Up to 49 in.
No Booster Option
19 lbs.
Best Travel System
$$$$$
Travel System
4-35 lbs. / Up to 1″ Below Top
Rear Facing Only
Rear Facing Only
37 lbs. (Stroller & Car Seat)
Best Value Travel System
$$
Travel System
4-30 lbs. / Up to 30″
Rear Facing Only
Rear Facing Only
24 lbs. (Stroller & Car Seat)